Granite Lodge: Home to a Forty-Niner and a yachtsman

Granite Lodge is shown in an 1885 photograph by renowned Manhattan photographer Willis Knowlton. Knowlton's studios were at 335 4th Ave., Manhattan, a building he shared with Tiffany Studios and which still stands today at 333-335 Park Ave. South.  Theodore Strange's son Edwin Bruton Strange II, 10 at the time, rides a pony while his two younger sisters Laura and Josephine (obscured) appear to be seated on the home's front steps behind him in the photo. (Photo by W. Knowlton, 335 Fourth Ave., Manhattan, N.Y., courtesy Westchester County Historical Society and Librarian Patrick Raftery)

Jonathan Gosman Kittle's 19th century estate on the east side of North Broadway in Irvington had at least a pair of names — first Granite Lodge and later Grey  Gables — and some interesting characters who wound up living on it.

Kittle gained control of the two-acre property from the heirs of recently deceased nonagenarian farmer Michael Mann in 1868. Mann and his family also owned a farm about two blocks north across what would become the Tarrytown line on the east side of Broadway when Tarrytown incorporated as a village in 1870, beating Irvington to the punch by two years.

Jonathan Gosman Kittle

Before 1870, the land north of Sunnyside Lane past what would become Lyndhurst was generally considered to be part of Irvington.

Kittle (1829-1893), was born in Red Hook, N.Y., to the Rev. Andrew Nicholas Kittle and Eliza (Gosman) Kittle. He went West to seek his fortune during the gold rush of 1849 at the tender age of 20. Like most of the Forty-Niners who actually made money off the gold fields, Kittle made his by running three-masted clipper ships that brought needed products for the gold fields from New York to San Francisco (and gold for banks and brokerage houses on the return trip). 

This advertisement is for the clipper ship California, ca. 1855, in a setting straight out of the California gold rush. It lists DeWitt, Kittle & Co. as its San Francisco agents, wth Randolph M. Cooley representing the firm from its New York offices at 88 Wall Street. (Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

Kittle partnered with an older, established businessman, Alfred DeWitt, to form DeWitt, Kittle & Co. in San Francisco with offices also in New York at 88 Wall Street. Kittle had family ties to DeWitt through Kittle's wife Harriette DeWitt (Allen) Kittle and Harriette's family, the Allens, were also part of the DeWitt, Kittle company.

After DeWitt's retirement in 1870. Kittle took full control, operating as Kittle & Co., and moving permanently in 1880 to the town of Ross in Marin County, California 1880 where he purchased a large estate called Sunnyside (no connection to Washington Irving's estate of the same name) from the heirs of the town's namesake. It was on that estate that he and his wife raised their family. The family would occupy the estate for a half century.

The heart of that estate remains as the Marin Art & Garden Center today.

Kittle sold Granite Lodge in 1882 to silk importer Theodore A. Strange, a longtime resident of the famed Alexander Jackson Davis-designed Gothic Revival mansion Ingleside in nearby Dobbs Ferry which was built and owned by his father, wealthy silk importer Edwin Bruton Strange. 

Ingleside is located north of Hastings between Broadway and the Hudson River. The building, with many alterations, since 1891 has been part of the 7-acre St. Christopher's Dobbs Ferry Campus and most recently its Kenneth Clarke Academy for young people with special needs at 71 S. Broadway.

The property was put up for sale for $12.5 million in 2024.

Architect Alexander Jackson Davis designed silk importer Edwin Bruton Strange's Dobbs Ferry mansion Ingleside (pictured) in 1854. It's the mansion where his son Theodore Albert Strange lived until 1882. At that point, Theodore Strange bought Granite Lodge and moved to Irvington. (Photo courtesy the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Columbia University)

Theodore Strange was a member of the family firm Strange & Brothers, which would diversify from the importation of raw silk and ribbons to the successful manufacture of silk goods in the U.S. for the American consumer market. It also added an extremely lucrative line of feathers and other accessories for women's hats, haute couture at the time.

Ingleside, built by Strange's Engish immigrant father Edwin Bruton Strange in 1854, still stands as part of St. Christopher's, Inc., 71 South Broadway, Dobbs Ferry, a residential treatment center serving special needs children.

Strange was a sportsman, a member of the New York Yacht Club who owned one of the premier yachts in the region, the Ariadne, a sloop that was a regular participant in New York Yacht Club events in New York Harbor. In fact, when it came time for retirement, Strange sold his Irvington estate and moved to Long Branch, New Jersey, a favorite haunt of U.S. presidents including Ulysses S. Grant, who watched at least one of Ariadne's races in in nearby New York Harbor.

Theodore A. Strange

The Strange family sold Granite Lodge, 130 N. Broadway, in 1915 to William S. Emery, who renamed it Grey Gables. Emery sold the property to the family of James Hall in early 1925. Emery died of a stroke at 58 several months later during a trip to California.

Hall purchased Greg Gables' neighboring Broadlawn estate at 120 North Broadway shortly thereafter, which almost tripled the size of his original holding. His heirs sold the combined properties, known as Broadlawn, in mid-1940. The property was developed in 1947 as Irvington Gardens apartments, with rents ranging from $87 per month for a 3-1/2 room apartment to $105 for a five-room apartment. Veterans were given preference for leases and federal funds helped complete the project.

The two-acre Theodore A. Strange property Granite Lodge, later Grey Gables (shown in an 1886 illustration), stood at 130 North Broadway, Irvington, N.Y. Today that property and the neighboring former 3.5-acre Broadlawn estate at 120 North Broadway have been redeveloped as the site of the Irvington Gardens co-op apartment complex, built in 1947. (The History of Westchester County, New York, Volume II, by J. Thomas Scharf, 1886. Public domain)

AUTHOR'S NOTE: Special thanks to Chet Kerr of the Irvington Historical Society for his research help with the Kittle family and property transfer documentation on this estate. 

* Click here for links to dozens of other Gilded Age stories by this author